Something weird and wonderful and maybe a little bit scary is going to happen next time you go to buy a pint of your favorite Ben & Jerry’s flavor.

First, you’ll saunter up to the freezer, confident that you know exactly what you want. But wait! What’s that?! Next to all the pints of Americone Dream and Chunky Monkey, there’s something new: Ben & Jerry’s Pint Slices! Thick slices of your favorite flavors, dipped in a dark chocolatey coating.

But now you’re faced with a dilemma: to pint, or to Pint Slice?

Take a beat. Don’t rush your decision. Luckily we have a handy guide for helping you along your journey: